Battle of the Day

Kate Upton vs Melanie Ribbe

Kate Upton in lingerie
Melanie Ribbe in a bikini

Kate Upton

Melanie Ribbe

For the last few years, Kate Upton has been lauded by men for her very feminine curves, while women criticized her for being a bit too soft and squishy, but Kate always seems to come out on top, as seen by her three cover spread with Sports Illustrated earlier this year.

Alas, all good things must come to an end as there is now solid competition for Kate's crown with hottie Charlotte McKinney. Charlotte not only has curves in all of the right places, but she is not quite as squishy looking as Kate is, although that may be want men desire. You tell us...

Who do you think is hotter, Kate or Charlotte?