To log on and post you will need to create an account in the forums even if you already registered on the main Hotness Rater site. These registrations are separate.
Actually I don't find these 2 girls really hot, just average looking, especially Allison Mack. Elisha Cuthbert is also not my type, but compared to Allison, she's better looking.
Oddly enough though I think Elisha Cuthbert is the cuter of the two, if you were to compare the two now, a decade later, Allison Mack sort of didn't change that much but Elisha's beauty has faded. Some girls age gracefully, most don't.