Well the fact that they are both Olympians, and good ones at that, really makes their attractiveness on the whole other scale for me, but I would have to give the edge here to Aly. It is a just a personal thing here, and I am a white male and I just so happen to be more attracted to Aly. That is not to say that Gabby is not beautiful, because she certainly is, and she is one heck of a gymnast too. It is hard to pick between two champions.