Hmm.. This is a tough one. I must say that I liked them both before they got crazy with the makeup, plastic surgery and all that. So yes, who to choose, probably Kim Kardashian. She was really hot back then, she looked very exotic. But now, she just looks very plastic-y and old. Which is sad as I think her natural beauty is one of a kind. I'm more into Courtney right now, she's aging gracefully for a mother of three (I think).