Caroline Kelley

Caroline Kelley

Caroline Kelley's Rating: 8.77/10info

Based on 115 votes from Hotness Rater voters

Won Against

  • Alyssa Arce in a bikini
    9.69/10
    Amanda Taylor in a bikini - ass
    9.68/10
    Hannah Ferguson in a bikini
    9.68/10
  • Melanie Iglesias
    9.67/10
    Miranda Jordan in lingerie - ass
    9.66/10
    Cara Zavaleta in lingerie
    9.65/10
  • Brooke Richards in lingerie
    9.63/10
    Anonymous
    9.59/10
    Meg Turney - Me in My Place - shows us around her room
    9.37/10
  • Jessica Lowndes
    9.36/10
    Tyra Banks
    9.31/10
    Syunka Ayami
    9.22/10

Lost Against

  • Janet Varney
    8.84/10
    Debby Ryan
    8.81/10
    Charley Manley
    8.78/10
  • Chanel Iman
    8.76/10
    Romee Strijd
    8.72/10
    Crystal Wang Xi Ran
    8.72/10
  • Polina Tkach
    8.71/10
    Ana Carolina Ugarte
    8.59/10
    Erin Heatherton
    8.51/10
  • Joyce Chao taking a selfie
    8.41/10
    Georgia Moffett
    8.36/10
    Nabilla Benattia taking a selfie
    8.35/10