Maggi Caruthers

Maggi Caruthers is also known as Maggie May

Maggi Caruthers in lingerie

Maggi Caruthers's Rating: 9.18/10info

Based on 80 votes from Hotness Rater voters

Won Against

  • Naya Rivera
    9.23/10
    Lindsay Ellingson
    9.22/10
    Amber Heard in lingerie - ass
    9.21/10
  • Johanna Lundback in lingerie - ass
    9.19/10
    Michelle Salituro in lingerie
    9.18/10
    Shay Maria in lingerie
    9.17/10
  • Terra Jo Wallace
    9.17/10
    Bar Paly
    9.15/10
    Hillary Fisher in a bikini
    9.15/10

Lost Against

  • Elisha Cuthbert in a bikini
    9.67/10
    Hope Dworaczyk in lingerie - ass
    9.67/10
    Hillary Fisher - ass
    9.67/10
  • Lina Posada in lingerie - ass
    9.67/10
    Alyssa Miller in a bikini
    9.63/10
    Sports Illustrated 2013 Swimsuit Edition.
    9.63/10
  • Emily Ratajkowski Sports Illustrated 2014 - Body Paint
    9.62/10
    Sports Illustrated 2013 Swimsuit Edition
    9.61/10
    Alejandra Guilmant in a bikini
    9.60/10

Maggi Caruthers Galleries