Maggi Caruthers

Maggi Caruthers is also known as Maggie May

Maggi Caruthers in a bikini

Maggi Caruthers's Rating: 9.61/10info

Based on 58 votes from Hotness Rater voters

Won Against

  • Laury Thilleman in a bikini
    8.76/10
    Courteney Cox
    8.73/10
    Christina Applegate in lingerie
    8.72/10
  • Karoline Herfurth
    8.67/10
    Holliday Grainger
    8.38/10
    Sammi Hanratty
    8.36/10
  • Bruna Marquezine
    Unrated
    Rose Williams
    Unrated
    Lea Michele leaving Whole Foods in LA 9/21/12
    Unrated
  • Julia Johansen
    Unrated

Lost Against

  • Viola Bailey masturbates by the pool in this Twistys photoshoot
    9.18/10
    Annabelle Angel in lingerie
    9.17/10
    Monica Bellucci
    8.92/10
  • Audrina Patridge
    8.87/10
    Amanda Seyfried
    8.84/10
    Gisele in lingerie - ass
    8.78/10
  • Kaley Cuoco the Big Bang Theory panel during 2010 Summer TCA Tour on July 28, 2010
    8.73/10
    Bella Thorne
    8.59/10
    LeAnn Rimes
    8.41/10
  • Di Yao
    8.24/10
    Kenza Fourati
    Unrated
    Lucie Donlan
    Unrated

Maggi Caruthers Galleries