Maggi Caruthers

Maggi Caruthers is also known as Maggie May

Maggie May Playmate Miss August 2014

Maggie May Playmate Miss August 2014

Maggi Caruthers's Rating: 9.60/10info

Based on 119 votes from Hotness Rater voters

Won Against

  • Anastasia Harris in a bikini
    9.63/10
    Diana Morales in lingerie
    9.63/10
    Kate Beckinsale
    9.63/10
  • Julie Henderson - ass
    9.62/10
    Isabela Soncini in lingerie
    9.62/10
    Amber Heard
    9.61/10
  • Erin Cummins in lingerie
    9.60/10
    Denise Schaefer in a bikini
    9.60/10
    Valerie Van Der Graaf in a bikini
    9.60/10
  • Catalina Uribe in a bikini
    9.60/10
    Natalia Starr in lingerie
    9.60/10
    Ela Savanas in a bikini
    9.59/10

Lost Against

  • Elizabeth Loaiza in lingerie
    9.62/10
    Paris Nichole in a bikini
    9.61/10
    Malena Morgan in lingerie - ass
    9.60/10
  • Shandi Finnessey in a bikini
    9.60/10
    Melissa Giraldo in a bikini
    9.59/10
    Sports Illustrated 2013 Swimsuit Edition
    9.59/10
  • Amy Willerton in a bikini
    9.59/10
    Amber Sym in a bikini
    9.58/10
    Lindsay Ellingson in lingerie
    9.57/10
  • Jessi June strips off her striped bikini in low light
    9.56/10
    Amy Willerton in a bikini
    9.56/10
    Catalina Otalvaro in lingerie - ass
    9.46/10

See more pictures and videos at Playboy Plus:

0004

Maggi Caruthers Galleries