Caroline Kelley

Caroline Kelley

Caroline Kelley's Rating: 9.25/10info

Based on 69 votes from Hotness Rater voters

Won Against

  • Valery Kuklishyna
    9.26/10
    Shay Mitchell
    9.24/10
    Jessica Chastain (upsizes) at the Late Show with David Letterman in New York 1/7/13
    9.20/10
  • Bruna Lirio in a bikini
    9.19/10
    Alexandra Burman
    9.16/10
    Scarlett Johansson
    9.14/10
  • Eva Mendes
    9.03/10
    Crissy Moran
    8.92/10
    Liu Fei Er in a bikini
    8.91/10
  • Jessica Marshall
    8.81/10
    Mia Kang for Sports Illustrated Swimsuit Edition 2017
    8.81/10
    Caitlin Arnett in lingerie
    8.80/10

Lost Against

  • Carla Ossa
    9.69/10
    Charlotte McKinney in lingerie
    9.67/10
    Alina Boyko in a bikini
    9.64/10
  • Amber Valentine
    9.62/10
    Candice Swanepoel
    9.56/10
    Aline Lima
    9.56/10
  • Katheryn Winnick
    9.56/10
    Alexandria DeBerry
    9.56/10
    Carla Ossa
    9.55/10
  • Taylor Swift  Red  Tour - Concert at the Staples Center in Los Angeles - August 19, 2013
    9.55/10
    Nadine Leopold
    9.51/10
    Odette Yustman
    9.34/10