Shelby Bay

Shelby Bay

Shelby Bay's Rating: 9.25/10info

Based on 51 votes from Hotness Rater voters

Won Against

  • Stacy Marie Fuson in a bikini
    9.61/10
    Cristina Hurtado in lingerie - ass
    9.56/10
    Lucy Mecklenburgh
    9.53/10
  • Emily Ratajkowski in lingerie
    9.42/10
    Marry Queen
    9.41/10
    Denise Milani
    9.24/10
  • Denise Milani in lingerie
    9.23/10
    Esti Ginzburg
    9.21/10
    Alexis Ren
    9.19/10
  • Allie Mason
    9.17/10
    Blake Lively
    9.14/10
    Kate Hudson
    9.12/10

Lost Against

  • Polly Parsons in lingerie
    9.67/10
    Catalina Otalvaro
    9.66/10
    Sarah Kohan in a bikini
    9.66/10
  • Misa Campo
    9.64/10
    Abby Champion
    9.63/10
    Georgina Howard in lingerie - ass
    9.60/10
  • Daniela Lopez
    9.59/10
    Madison Headrick in lingerie
    9.58/10
    Hayley Hughes
    9.29/10
  • Xenia Deli
    9.27/10
    Rachel Peters
    9.23/10
    Kayslee Don Collins
    9.22/10