Shelby Bay

Shelby Bay taking a selfie

Shelby Bay's Rating: 9.54/10info

Based on 41 votes from Hotness Rater voters

Won Against

  • Kate Upton
    9.21/10
    Shantel VanSanten
    9.19/10
    Brooklyn Decker
    9.18/10
  • Megan Williams in lingerie
    9.18/10
    Tatiana Platon in lingerie
    9.15/10
    Scarlett Johansson
    9.13/10
  • Kate Grigorieva
    9.09/10
    Arianny Celeste in a bikini
    9.07/10
    Vita Sidorkina in lingerie
    8.95/10

Lost Against

  • Carla Ossa
    9.69/10
    Brittany Oldehoff
    9.68/10
    Amanda Saccomanno in a bikini
    9.68/10
  • Jessica-Jane Clement in lingerie
    9.66/10
    Reese Witherspoon
    9.63/10
    Ann-Margret
    9.60/10
  • Adriana Lima in lingerie
    9.59/10
    Costanza Caracciolo
    9.58/10
    Sandra Kubicka
    9.55/10