Shelby Bay

Shelby Bay in a bikini

Shelby Bay's Rating: 9.66/10info

Based on 93 votes from Hotness Rater voters

Won Against

  • Playboy Playmate of the Month August 1982
    9.68/10
    Carla Ossa
    9.68/10
    Alejandra Guilmant in a bikini
    9.67/10
  • Teeny B Bikinis
    9.67/10
    Fiona Barron
    9.67/10
    Jillian Beyor in lingerie
    9.67/10
  • Natalia Vélez wearing Plaid bikini
    9.67/10
    Emma Kuziara in lingerie
    9.67/10
    Nicci Pisarri in a bikini - ass
    9.67/10
  • Lingerie
    9.66/10
    Shania Twain
    9.66/10
    Jehane Paris in a bikini
    9.66/10

Lost Against

  • Jessica Ashley
    9.74/10
    Rachel Cook in lingerie
    9.71/10
    Audrey Allen in a bikini
    9.71/10
  • Denise Schaefer
    9.68/10
    Amber Sym in lingerie
    9.68/10
    All Natural
    9.68/10
  • Brittany Oldehoff
    9.68/10
    Roza Abdurazakova in lingerie
    9.68/10
    Barbara Palvin
    9.67/10
  • Ana De Armas
    9.67/10
    Natalia Vélez wearing Plaid bikini
    9.67/10
    Emily DiDonato
    9.67/10