Carly McKillip

Carly McKillip

Carly McKillip's Rating: 9.19/10info

Based on 91 votes from Hotness Rater voters

Won Against

  • Heather Crook in a bikini
    9.65/10
    Erika Botero in lingerie - ass
    9.63/10
    Amanda Stronegger in lingerie - ass
    9.59/10
  • Meri Gulin
    9.59/10
    2011 Sports Illustrated Swimsuit Edition for South Africa
    9.56/10
    Lucy Bayet in lingerie
    9.39/10
  • Luisana Lopilato in lingerie - ass
    9.29/10
    Nicole Neal in lingerie - ass
    9.23/10
    Katheryn Winnick
    9.22/10

Lost Against

  • Jessica-Jane Clement in lingerie
    9.66/10
    Brooklyn Decker on the 2010 cover of Sports Illustrated Swimsuit Edition
    9.64/10
    Sports Illustrated 2013 Swimsuit Edition
    9.62/10
  • Gio Ott in a bikini
    9.62/10
    Meri Gulin in lingerie
    9.61/10
    Lena Gercke
    9.60/10
  • Aly Michalka
    9.58/10
    Bar Refaeli
    9.57/10
    Vanessa Lengies VH1 Save the Music Foundation benefit -- Los Angeles, Aug. 26, 2011
    9.56/10