Tobey Maguire

Tobey Maguire

Tobey Maguire's Rating: 9.09/10info

Based on 102 votes from Hotness Rater voters

Won Against

  • Kevin Costner
    8.79/10
    Johnny Depp
    8.77/10
    Alexander Skarsgård
    8.72/10
  • Jake Johnson
    8.69/10
    Zac Efron
    8.54/10
    Anonymous
    8.36/10
  • Andrew Garfield
    8.36/10
    Sebastien Roberts
    8.34/10
    Patrick Dempsey
    8.32/10
  • Anonymous
    8.31/10
    Cody Jaycot
    8.23/10
    Anonymous
    8.17/10

Lost Against

  • Dennis Quaid
    8.85/10
    Fernando Noriega
    8.79/10
    Robert Redford
    8.78/10
  • Xavier Samuel
    8.76/10
    Nick Jonas
    8.73/10
    Jef Holm
    8.56/10
  • Jake Gyllenhaal
    8.56/10
    Anonymous
    8.48/10
    Logan Henderson
    8.07/10
  • Matt Damon
    7.83/10
    Gaspard Ulliel
    Unrated
    Orlando Bloom
    Unrated