Tobey Maguire

Tobey Maguire

Tobey Maguire's Rating: 8.95/10info

Based on 53 votes from Hotness Rater voters

Won Against

  • Jesse Eisenberg
    9.65/10
    Taylor Lautner
    9.55/10
    Henry Cavill
    9.51/10
  • James McAvoy
    9.49/10
    Logan Lerman
    9.39/10
    Leonardo DiCaprio
    9.04/10

Lost Against

  • Matt Bomer shirtless, showing off his amazing abs
    9.71/10
    Ryan Reynolds
    9.64/10
    Taylor Lautner
    9.57/10
  • Matt Bomer looking super hot in a suit
    9.52/10
    Orlando Bloom
    9.43/10
    Anonymous in a bikini
    9.28/10