Tobey Maguire

Tobey Maguire

Tobey Maguire's Rating: 7.84/10info

Based on 59 votes from Hotness Rater voters

Won Against

  • Idris Elba
    7.20/10
    Anonymous
    7.19/10
    Anonymous in a bikini
    7.07/10
  • Tyler Glenn
    7.04/10
    Anonymous
    6.22/10
    Muhammad Ali
    6.19/10

Lost Against

  • Joel McHale
    8.14/10
    Shemar Moore shows off his six pack at The Beyonce Concert August 2, 2014
    8.03/10
    Anonymous
    7.81/10
  • Matt Smith
    7.71/10
    Shirtless American Olympic Swimmer Matt Grevers
    7.65/10
    Anonymous
    7.57/10