Tobey Maguire

Tobey Maguire

Tobey Maguire's Rating: 8.61/10info

Based on 34 votes from Hotness Rater voters

Won Against

  • Leonardo DiCaprio
    8.82/10
    Damon Lipari
    8.62/10
    James Dean
    8.58/10
  • Anonymous
    8.57/10
    James McAvoy
    8.39/10
    Robert Redford
    8.33/10
  • Justin Chambers
    8.32/10
    Jason Mraz
    8.29/10
    Alexander Skarsgård
    8.26/10

Lost Against

  • Adam Rodrigue
    9.00/10
    Ryan Gosling
    8.68/10
  • John Francis Daley
    8.59/10
    Leonardo DiCaprio
    8.42/10
  • Arjun Rampal
    8.38/10
    Justin Theroux
    8.20/10
  • The king lives!  This Elvis has camel toe!
    3.30/10