Tobey Maguire

Tobey Maguire

Tobey Maguire's Rating: 8.16/10info

Based on 28 votes from Hotness Rater voters

Won Against

  • Leonardo DiCaprio
    8.71/10
    James Dean
    8.50/10
    Damon Lipari
    8.47/10
  • Anonymous
    8.38/10
    Robert Redford
    8.30/10
    James McAvoy
    7.96/10
  • Jason Mraz
    7.90/10
    Iker Casillas
    7.65/10
    Gazza
    6.99/10

Lost Against

  • Ryan Gosling
    8.56/10
    Leonardo DiCaprio
    8.11/10
  • Justin Theroux
    7.92/10
    The king lives!  This Elvis has camel toe!
    3.79/10