Tobey Maguire

Tobey Maguire

Tobey Maguire's Rating: 8.70/10info

Based on 33 votes from Hotness Rater voters

Won Against

  • Will Smith
    7.35/10
    Anonymous
    7.34/10
    Stephen Geoffreys
    7.17/10
  • Bob Dylan
    7.17/10
    Anonymous
    7.14/10
    Anonymous
    6.35/10
  • Fui-On Shing
    4.44/10
    Hank Williams
    4.30/10
    Adam Garcia
    Unrated

Lost Against

  • Matt Bomer looking super hot in a suit
    9.31/10
    Enrique Iglesias
    9.12/10
    Chris Pine
    9.08/10
  • Anonymous in a bikini
    8.88/10
    Patrick Dempsey
    8.72/10
    Anonymous
    8.55/10
  • Iker Casillas
    8.23/10
    Anonymous
    4.53/10
    Diplo
    Unrated