Tobey Maguire

Tobey Maguire

Tobey Maguire's Rating: Unratedinfo

Based on 40 votes from Hotness Rater voters

Won Against

  • Matthew McConaughey
    9.44/10
    Taylor Lautner
    9.08/10
    Justas Valiukas
    8.67/10
  • Tom Hunt
    8.55/10
    Adam Rodrigue
    8.55/10
    Luis Garcia
    8.33/10
  • David Tennant
    8.29/10
    Evan Longoria
    8.27/10
    Cary Grant
    8.11/10
  • Tomas Berdych
    7.87/10
    Peter O'Toole
    7.72/10
    Redfoo
    7.66/10

Lost Against

  • Matt Bomer looking super hot in a suit
    9.56/10
    Matt Bomer
    9.54/10
    Joel Rush
    9.49/10
  • Jake Silbermann
    9.41/10
    Darren Criss
    9.24/10
    Joe Manganiello
    9.12/10
  • Andrew Garfield
    8.90/10
    Brock Kelly
    8.80/10
    Johnny Depp
    8.75/10
  • David Beckham
    8.66/10
    James McAvoy
    8.48/10
    Zayn Malik
    8.48/10