Tobey Maguire

Tobey Maguire

Tobey Maguire's Rating: 8.64/10info

Based on 50 votes from Hotness Rater voters

Won Against

  • Garrett Hedlund
    8.81/10
    Robert Redford
    8.66/10
    Jef Holm
    8.55/10
  • Anonymous
    8.41/10
    Sean O'Pry
    8.34/10
    American Olympic Swimmer Matt Grevers
    8.28/10
  • Zachary Quinto
    8.25/10
    Hugh Grant
    8.21/10
    Gerald Butler
    8.20/10
  • Jim Carrey
    8.18/10
    Robert De Niro
    8.16/10
    Peter O'Toole
    8.14/10

Lost Against

  • Henry Cavill
    9.61/10
    Zac Efron
    9.56/10
    Jensen Ackles
    9.54/10
  • Zac Efron
    9.44/10
    Ryan Kwanten
    9.42/10
    Darren Criss
    9.35/10
  • Ryan Reynolds
    9.24/10
    Matt Bomer
    9.14/10
    Eric Dane
    9.08/10
  • Andrew Stetson in lingerie
    8.93/10
    Beau Mirchoff
    8.87/10
    Darren Criss
    8.76/10