Tobey Maguire

Tobey Maguire

Tobey Maguire's Rating: Unratedinfo

Based on 41 votes from Hotness Rater voters

Won Against

  • Penn Badgley
    9.44/10
    Andrew Stetson in lingerie
    8.99/10
    Tom Parker
    8.92/10
  • Darren Criss
    8.26/10
    Kevin Costner
    7.76/10
    Bob Dylan
    7.68/10

Lost Against

  • Matt Bomer
    9.59/10
    Joel Rush
    9.57/10
    Paul Walker
    9.52/10
  • Henry Cavill
    9.25/10
    Josh Duhamel
    9.22/10
    Leonardo DiCaprio
    9.17/10