Tobey Maguire

Tobey Maguire

Tobey Maguire's Rating: 8.62/10info

Based on 49 votes from Hotness Rater voters

Won Against

  • Ashton Kutcher
    9.45/10
    Anonymous in a bikini
    9.39/10
    Andrew Garfield
    9.37/10
  • Robert Downey Jr
    9.02/10
    Dennis Quaid
    8.99/10
    Francisco Lachowski
    8.95/10
  • Xavier Samuel
    8.90/10
    Kit Harington
    8.81/10
    Ian Somerhalder
    8.81/10

Lost Against

  • Josh Duhamel
    8.95/10
    Ashton Kutcher
    8.92/10
    James Franco
    8.91/10
  • Darren Criss
    8.90/10
    Dennis Quaid
    8.85/10
    Matthew Davis
    8.82/10
  • Ian Somerhalder
    8.81/10
    Matthew McConaughey
    8.59/10
    Let me know what you think(:
    8.44/10