Shelby Nicole

Shelby Nicole in lingerie

Shelby Nicole's Rating: 9.52/10info

Based on 58 votes from Hotness Rater voters

Won Against

  • Casie Kimball in a bikini
    9.67/10
    Kara Monaco in a bikini
    9.64/10
    Georgia Grace Martin
    9.59/10
  • Mara Roldan in a bikini
    9.58/10
    Mishka Ivana aka Michelle Ivana, a Russian-descent American Fashion Model
    9.56/10
    Jarah Mariano
    9.26/10
  • Emily Ratajkowski
    9.23/10
    Willow Hand
    9.23/10
    Josephine Skriver
    9.20/10
  • Ginger Jolie
    9.20/10
    Playboy Cybergirl - Ashleigh Hannah Nude Photos & Videos at Playboy Plus!
    9.18/10
    Cassie Scerbo
    9.17/10

Lost Against

  • Jill Wagner
    9.68/10
    Constance Nunes in lingerie
    9.67/10
    Sara Jean Underwood - ass
    9.67/10
  • Kelly Monaco
    9.66/10
    Amanda Cerny
    9.66/10
    Missy Robinson
    9.65/10
  • Kayla Love - ass
    9.64/10
    Emily Ratajkowski
    9.63/10
    Stacy Marie Fuson in a bikini
    9.60/10
  • Meagan Pastorchik
    9.60/10
    Johanne Landbo in a bikini
    9.58/10
    Kira Shipway
    9.58/10