Shelby Bay

Shelby Bay in a bikini

Shelby Bay's Rating: 9.67/10info

Based on 43 votes from Hotness Rater voters

Won Against

  • Carla Ossa
    9.70/10
    Erika Eleniak in a bikini
    9.66/10
    Helga Lovekaty in a bikini - ass
    9.66/10
  • Miranda Jordan in lingerie - ass
    9.66/10
    Bikini digitals
    9.66/10
    Kara del Toro
    9.66/10
  • Carla Ossa in a bikini
    9.64/10
    Sarah MacDonald in a bikini
    9.63/10
    Johanna Lundback in a bikini
    9.63/10
  • Christina Applegate
    9.59/10
    Jessa Hinton in a bikini
    9.58/10
    Devin Brugman in a bikini
    9.56/10

Lost Against

  • Hillary Fisher - ass
    9.68/10
    Kalin Olson in a bikini
    9.67/10
    Jaime Bergman
    9.66/10
  • Maria Ozawa in a bikini
    9.66/10
    Sara Jean Underwood
    9.64/10
    Anna Katharina in a bikini
    9.64/10
  • Cora Skinner in a bikini
    9.64/10
    Emmanuelle Chriqui
    9.63/10
    Sarah MacDonald in a bikini
    9.63/10
  • Nina Agdal
    9.63/10
    Nina Agdal in lingerie
    9.61/10
    Jami Ferrell
    9.60/10