Shelby Bay

Shelby Bay in a bikini

Shelby Bay in a bikini

Shelby Bay's Rating: 9.62/10info

Based on 41 votes from Hotness Rater voters

Won Against

  • Gabriela Salles in a bikini
    9.58/10
    Bryana Holly in a bikini
    9.55/10
    Diana Morales in lingerie - ass
    9.29/10
  • Krystal Dawson in a bikini
    9.28/10
    Ksenia Solo
    9.25/10
    Julianna Sharkey in a bikini
    9.24/10
  • Shay Mitchell
    9.19/10
    Tuppence Middleton
    8.73/10
    Elizabeth Banks
    8.44/10
  • Ryan Newman
    8.40/10
    Sammi Hanratty
    8.05/10
    Michelle Hunziker
    7.77/10

Lost Against

  • Erika Eleniak in a bikini
    9.67/10
    All Natural
    9.67/10
    Elizabeth Hurley in a bikini
    9.67/10
  • Jayde Nicole
    9.65/10
    Allison Holton
    9.65/10
    Rachel Nichols
    9.64/10
  • Michelle Keegan in a bikini
    9.63/10
    Alina Boyko in a bikini - ass
    9.62/10
    Alexis Knapp
    9.62/10
  • Jennifer Hurt
    9.61/10
    Hot Christmas Girls
    9.61/10
    Alina Lopez
    9.52/10