Carlie Butler

Carlie Butler taking a selfie

Carlie Butler's Rating: 9.13/10info

Based on 57 votes from Hotness Rater voters

Won Against

  • Paula Shy in  Mirror 1  for The Life Erotic - Paula Shy strips by the window as she masturbates on the stairs.
    Unrated

Lost Against

  • Phoebe Malisz Oum in a bikini
    9.64/10
    Madison Edwards in a beach bikini photo shoot in Sydney, 05/01/2017
    9.64/10
    Catalina Otalvaro in lingerie
    9.63/10
  • Amber Valentine
    9.62/10
    Candice Swanepoel in lingerie
    9.60/10
    Isabela Soncini in a bikini
    9.60/10
  • Casie Kimball
    9.60/10
    Lauren Stoner in a bikini
    9.60/10
    Laura Giraudi
    9.60/10