I have to agree with you on this one. He has this pretty boy, guy next door look and probably wouldn't appeal to someone who prefers rugged boyish guy. I like his eyes too.I have to say, he's got gorgeous eyes. He's a little too pretty boy for me, but his eyes are soulful and a beautiful color.
I also think that he's quite hot, with a nice singing voice to boot. I don't mind the pretty boy look, I think it suits him very well. I just don't like him shaving his eyebrows, it makes him trying hard to look cool and manly.