Shay Mitchell

Shay Mitchell is also known as Shannon Ashley Mitchell

Shay Mitchell taking a selfie

Shay Mitchell's Rating: 8.65/10info

Based on 88 votes from Hotness Rater voters

Won Against

  • Holly Hendrix - ass
    8.04/10
    Luodan Wang
    8.03/10
  • Sara Ramirez
    8.03/10
    Lisa Frelin
    7.72/10
  • Anonymous
    6.81/10
    Christina Milian
    Unrated
  • Paula Brancati
    Unrated
    Images of Holly Hendrix from the evil angel set Holly: Big Black Cock Interracial Anal
    Unrated

Lost Against

  • Gabriela Salles in a bikini
    9.71/10
    Ciara Price in a bikini
    9.67/10
    Elizabeth Turner
    9.64/10
  • Iskra Lawrence
    9.59/10
    Mollie King photoshoot November 2010
    9.49/10
    Holliday Grainger
    9.31/10
  • Victoria Justice
    9.29/10
    Anne Vyalitsyna
    9.22/10
    Amy Smart Yes on Prop 2 party in Los Angeles
    9.21/10